Cinematic Flashback
Cinematic Flashback
Welcome to the Cinematic Flashback Podcast! Buckle up and hop into the Way Back Machine as we journey through the wild, bold, and unforgettable films of the 1970s!

Each episode, we're breaking down a classic flick or digging up forgotten gems from cinema’s most revolutionary decade. We'll introduce you to the iconic faces, dive into the captivating plots, and unpack the cultural impact these films had—and still have today. From gritty street tales to groundbreaking indie hits, we’ll explore how each movie shaped cinema history and answer the all-important question: “Did it groove through the decades, or lose its beat?”

Whether you’re a film fanatic, a weekend watcher, or just dipping your toes into the deep waters of 70s cinema, Cinematic Flashback is your ticket to rediscovering why this era changed movies forever. Join us as we relive the stories, characters, and moments that defined a generation of filmmaking.
May 20, 2026

Ryan and Tatum O’Neal Shine in Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon (1973)

Ryan and Tatum O’Neal Shine in Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon (1973)
Ryan and Tatum O’Neal Shine in Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon (1973)
Cinematic Flashback
Ryan and Tatum O’Neal Shine in Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon (1973)

In this episode of the Cinematic Flashback Podcast, Chuck Bryan and Matt Sargent take a deep dive into Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon (1973), the Depression-era road movie starring real-life father and daughter Ryan and Tatum O’Neal. What begins as a simple grifter story slowly reveals itself to be one of the most heartfelt and emotionally layered films of the 1970s.

The discussion explores how Paper Moon emerged from the bold experiment known as The Directors Company — a short-lived attempt by Paramount and Gulf+Western to give major filmmakers unprecedented creative freedom with low-budget productions. Chuck and Matt discuss how Paper Moon emerged during a period when studios were giving filmmakers more creative freedom, while also exploring Peter Bogdanovich’s direction, the film’s low-budget production, and why the movie became such a major success in 1973.

The episode also examines the unforgettable chemistry between Ryan and Tatum O’Neal, Tatum’s Academy Award-winning performance, the film’s black-and-white cinematography by László Kovács, and why Addie Loggins may actually be the true lead of the movie. Along the way, Chuck and Matt discuss con artists, Depression-era America, Madeline Kahn’s scene-stealing performance, the emotional ambiguity of the ending, and why the film still resonates decades later.

Does Paper Moon groove through the decades or lose its beat? Join us as we hop into the Wayback Machine and revisit one of the most charming, funny, and surprisingly emotional films of 1973.

Links & Contact Website:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com

Contact Us:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com/contact/

Listen to Previous Episodes:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com/episodes/

Leave a Review:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com/reviews/new/

Read the Blog:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com/blog/

Subscribe:
https://www.cinematicflashback.com/follow/

Share the Show:
Tell your movie-loving friends!

Other Podcast You Might Enjoy:

  • Surely You Can't Be Serious Podcast
  • 30 Something Movie Podcast
  • A Film By Podcast
  • Dockingbay 77
  • Def Dave's 1984
  • Accidental Legends
  • Phasers Set to Stun
  • Children of the 80s

0:01 But who got your ticket to Saint Joe? Who got your knee high in a Coney Island? And throw in twenty dollars extra, not to mention eighty five cents for that telegram. You wouldn't have had any of that without me. Now, I didn't have to take it, but I took you, didn't I all right? I think that's fair enough. We're both a little better off. We'll get to Saint Joe. I get myself a little better car. Fair is fair. Now break your knee high and eat your Coney Island. I bought my two hundred dollars. I don't have your two hundred dollars no more. And you know it. If you don't give me my two hundred dollars, I'm gonna tell please man how you gotten. He'll make you give it to me because it's mine.

0:47 But I don't have. Then get it. Welcome to the Cinematic Flashback Podcast. Get ready to hop into the wayback machine as we journey through the wild, bold, and unforgettable films of the nineteen seventies. Each episode, we break down a classic movie or a forgotten jim seeing how we performed then and now and wrapping things up by asking did it groof of the decades or did. It lose its feed? I am your host, Chuck Bryan, and today we are reviewing Peter Bogdanovich's nineteen seventy three film Paper Moon, starring real life father daughter Ryan and Tatum O'Neil matt. Today we've got depression era grifters, a nine year old who just might be the smartest person in the room, and something a little bigger. What happens when Hollywood decides to hand the keys over to the directors and just see what they can do with it?

1:47 How the heck are you? Man? I am well, and as always I am your trusty sidekick, And if you wait just a minute, I will have this personalized bible all ready for you, all printed in child of the major gold letters. This was the first time I saw Paper Moon, and it was so very different from the sting. We probably could have worked this one into last month's road trip theme. What do you think? I agree we should have seen the film before we would have known. But it was it was, It was fun, and it's fun how our path through nineteen seventies has taken us on these side jaunts. If you will, I might say, yeah. But as as we will see, there's a there's a big heart inside of this story. Yeah for sure, Matt, who's talking to us today? I found a comment on our Breaking Away Encore presentation, and this is actually pretty neat.

2:40 We have a subscriber named Steve Bassford and he's a regular on our Facebook page. Now you know how much I liked Breaking. Away, right? I had a yeah, yeah, long history with that movie as a young person, and I just love it. Well. Steve has written a book called Breaking Away, The Quintessential Underdog Movie, which I one hundred percent agree with him. It is absolutely the quintessential underdog movie. Steve has done a deep dive into every scene, the cast, the brains behind the movie. He interviewed the actors like Amy Wright who played Moucher's girlfriend, Eddie van Guys who played the Italian villain, and Moore. If you like the movie Breaking Away, and maybe if you liked it half as much as I like it, then we recommend that you pick up a copy of Steve's book, Breaking Away, the Quintessential Underdog Movie.

3:28 Where can we purchase this book? You can purchase it on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and most bookseller websites. We appreciate Steve and he has been with the Cinematic Flashback for some time. I have always appreciated Steve, and he gives really great feedback on Facebook. He would have been a fun person to have on that podcast, and hopefully as our reach expands and people start suggesting movies, they might also say, Hey, I happen to have written this book about this movie, and then we'd say, Wow, that might be a great person to have as a special guest. So I think we might have missed it with Steve since he had such a great book in so many details on Breaking Away. But honestly, listen to our podcast read his book, I think you'll get even more out of what I consider to be one of the coolest films of the nineteen seventies.

4:16 Well, let's begin talking about today's movie, paper Moon, and I want to start with the very first credit that you're going to see when you watch the film. It says that Paper Moon was produced by the director's company, and this is not the first time we've come across them on The Cinematic Flashback. In the intro, I tease this idea about what happens when Hollywood hands the keys over to directors and just let them go. Well, this is that story. By mid nineteen sixties, Paramount is going through its struggles. You know, it's not a dead studio, but it's definitely on the ropes. There were eight studios in Hollywood, and somehow Paramount was number nine. So how do you fix a failing studio? Well, this is where Golf and Western Industries steps in, led by Charles Bluehorn, and he buys the studio. Now, Bluehorn makes a key move.

5:12 He promotes Robert Evans to head of production. And we've mentioned Robert Evans before things start to turn around over at Paramount. You get a major hit with Love Story starring Ryan O'Neil and Ally McGraw. It is a huge box office and it's not just one hit. Paramount starts putting together a run with films like Rosemary's Baby, Love Story, The Godfather, Chinatown. Paramount begins to lead this new Hollywood wave. But Bluehorn he's thinking bigger than just making these hits. He's looking at different ways in which to make movies, a way in which there is less studio oversight and more creative freedom given to the directors. He cuts a deal with three of the hottest directors in Hollywood, Francis for Coppola, William Friedkin, and Peter Bogdanovitch, and the idea is pretty simple. They can make whatever film they want, just keep the budget under three million dollars and guess what it appears to work. Bogdanovitch delivers Paper Moon, which is a big hit. Copola follows it up with the Conversation, so The Conversation did not financially do as well as Paper Moon, and Freakin he never made a film for the Director's Company. He went off to make his film The Exorcist, which exceeded the three million dollar budget just a little bit. The real problem with the Director's Company.

6:39 You had these three filmmakers who loved the idea of creative freedom, but had no real interest in building something together. When Bogdanovich follows up Paper Moon with Daisy Miller and it's a flop, the whole thing starts to unravel. Can you imagine getting three of these high powered directors who are used to being you know, type A personalities and directs and try to get them to collaborate and work together. I think it was maybe doomed from the start. Have you ever heard of United Artist? Yes? So United Artist was a similar idea that was more focused around the actors. So it was started up way back when by Charlie Chaplin, and the idea is it gives these actors more agency in the scripts and in the projects that they're doing, and at the same time, it gives them, on the other side, more of that uptake to get more out of it. And Bluehorn was looking to try to do that specifically with directors because at the time, if you'll remember the movies that were really big hits starting I mean even starting with Easy Writer, were these films that were really ridiculously cheap to mate but had a huge boon. Bluehorn is the president of Gulf and Western, so of course he's looking how can I make movies for a little money that makes a lot back at the box office.

8:00 I mean, I don't disagree with the idea of limiting the budget a little bit because it means that the creative people that are making them will feel more free to do things that might not be guaranteed to be winners. Right, if you're spending twenty million dollars, it's like you're going to use the formula because you can't afford to not make back its money plus something, whereas if it's three million dollars, I mean, even back then, three million dollars was not very much when you look at what an entire production of a film has to be. So the idea that you might blow three million dollars on swing and a miss, sure, you can do ten of those for the cost of one apocalypse now or something.

8:40 Right, Oh gosh, yeah, to quote meat Loaf, two out of three eighth bad. And we got paper Moon, and we got The Conversation, and if you look at their budgets, they're all under three million. And we get to talk about Paper Moon today. If you look at both those films, I mean, the Conversation very important, film, really interesting, but it takes a lot of intention to watch that movie. It's a little bit like you really got to follow what's going on, and there's a lot going on, and of course Gene Hackman on the screen is always going to be intense, right, So it's a tougher. Watch in my opinion than Paper Moon, which, like you, this was my first time seeing this movie, though I had heard about it for years, and unfortunately it was probably what I heard about was the conflict between Ryan O'Neill and Tatum O'Neill and in their later life all of that rigormarole, which is all very sad. I mean, honestly, there's no other word for it's just sad. Yeah, because in this movie she is so amazing.

9:36 Go ahead and give us a synopsis of paper Mode. We'll do My father and daughter, Ryan and Tatumneil team up as slick con artists Moses Prey and Addie Logins in nineteen thirties Kansas, when Mose is unexpectedly saddled with getting the nine year old Addie to relatives in Missouri after the death of her mother. His attempt to duper out of her money backfires and he's forced to take her on as a partner. Swindling their way through farm country, the pair is nearly done in by a burlesque dancer played by Madeline Cohn and an angry boot lagger. Well, I think we are ready to get into the production details, but first we need to take a quick break. Madic flash Back and Madic flash Back.

10:25 Deep your snip. Hi Cancels nineteen thirty six, Out of the Darkest Days of the depression comes the adventures of two unlikely con artists, mos Prey and his companion Addie Loggins. Oh erdy is a bootlegger. Oh no, sir, not me. Friend, must be some mistake. Ryan O'Neill is mos Prey. Tata O'Neil, daughter of Ryan O'Neill, is Addie Logghams our very first film role. This is the Peter Bogdanovitch production Paper Moon.

11:09 Say it's only a paper more tailing over a cardboard, right, I'm crazy? Keep your side inside up, Keep it up. I'm telling us time almost got down. Jail mystics. You have Oh my god, stop that paper. I'm gonna hit him down. Don't don't you go making the decisions. I make the decisions. All you gotta do is look like a pretty little girl shooting at us.

11:54 Isn't he gone? You met my mom in a bar room. Just because a man meets a woman in a bar room don't mean he's your paw. Eat your coney Island. You don't have to worry. I ain't about to leave some poor little child stranded in the middle of nowhere. I got scruples too. You know you know what that is scruples. Now. I don't know what it is, but if you've gotten, be sure that they've long somebody else. We ain't gonna make it. You're going to ruin it, ain't you? Hang on? Oh Daily Wall, don't miss this one from the maker off the Last Picture Show and What's up?

12:47 Doc? Won't be sorry? Welcome back. Let's get into the production details. Paper Moon saw its wide release on May ninth, nineteen seventy three, and was distributed by Paramount Pictures. It had a running time of one hundred and two minutes. With a budget of two point five million, The movie would go on to gross thirty one million at the box office. It was based on the novel Addie Prey by Joe David Brown. Director Peter Bogdanovitch thought it sounded too much like a snake or a lizard. While selecting music for the film, he came across the nineteen thirty three standard It's only a paper Moon, with the two words paper moon jumping out. He felt that it captured the film's idea that something fragile and not quite real can still feel magical if you believe in it. The screenplay was by Alvin Sargent, The cinematographer was Laslo Kovak's. He did six films with Bogdanovic and his breakthrough came earlier with Easy Rider. The movie was edited by Verna Fields. Among the films that she edited included Bogdanovic's What's Up, Doc, George Lucas's American Graffiti, and Spielberg's The Sugarland Express. In that other summertime favorite movie, Jaws, The film was nominated for three Academy Awards. Both Madeline conn and Tatum O'Neil were nominated for Best Supporting Actress.

14:07 Tatum won, and it made her the youngest competitive Academy Award winner at the age of ten. And I think she would have won for Best Actress in a Leading Role, but that's just my opinion. Coincidentally, Linda Blair was also nominated that year as Reagan from The Exorcist. Blair was twelve years old. The film would go on to spawn a TV series that featured Christopher Connelly in the role of Mo's and Jodie Foster as Addie. Papermoon has a ninety one percent critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes and in ninety five percents audience rating. Matt Why don't we talk about this cast. I'm going to start out with the lead character played by Ryan O'Neill, Mose Prey or Moses Prey.

14:47 I sell a good book, ma'am, just moving through the country with the Lord's good news. Eddie child, don't you have your aunt Billy living in Saint Joseph. Saint Joseph, Missouri. It's her poor mother's sister, child, only known relative. That's all. You're driving your chariot to Missouri. Sir, you could deliver this child Hurricanehull. Well, I wouldn't exactly call. It a chariot, Reverend. I'll write the woman a letter tonight. Hold it. I have to think him on this, you know. I mean, I may have to make a few stops along the way. I never travel with no child before, but I got no place to go. Well, as the Lord, expect to have no choice to act. Hellad works in mysterious ways.

15:28 Ryan had hoped this film would exonerate him from the overwhelming success of Love Story. The success of that film threatened to type cast him as an ivy league yuppie. You know, Matt, we've talked about Love Story a couple of times. At some point I think we might need to bite the bullet and just review it, because maybe you can get a guest to do that one. I just I cannot stand that movie. I'll have to see about that one. I can't believe the overwhelming impact that that movie had in nineteen seventy. It was I think we were watching that film. The kid stays in the picture. It's it's a good movie. Yeah, if you haven't seen this movie yet, you do need. To watch it. It's a story about rise and fall of Robert Evans. Yeah, it goes through a whole detail of what we were talking about, how he turned around Paramount Pictures and then you know, kind of the fallout in his life. Obviously, Alan McGrath figures into that picture a little bit. Along with some of these earlier films like Love Story. It was really interesting. I enjoyed watching it. It really tells you a lot of the backstory of what was going on with the whole movie industry. Then I will tell you, as someone who lived through nineteen seventy and seventy one and having four sisters, Love Story was probably launched into wildly popularity because every girl had to go see it.

16:51 Yes, right, it was a chick flick of chick flicks and was it the start of the chick flick? I think it was definitely the starting seed of that whole genre. I have a little bit of trivia about it. Who was also up to play Mo's prey? What would you think of Paul Newman? I think he might have been Okay, he might have been too old for the role at the time, Yeah, because he would not have come off as the way Ryan O'Neil was. He was. Yeah, he was a grifter. Yeah, he knew stuff. He wasn't He wasn't polished, you know, he was definitely doing the standard grifts that he had heard about. He wasn't. Paul Newman was in the sting the very experienced con artist type one, So I think I wouldn't have He's a good actor, so maybe he would have been.

17:35 Okay, let me pitch another one. What is and these are Bob Evans regulars? Now, what about Jack Nicholson? Uh? No, Jack Nicholson would not have been good. I think it would have been a different film. I think there'd been no relationship between Addie and most no relationship whatsoever, and we know we've seen that in other Jack nicholson movies. The guy does not share screen with anyone, and one of them most endearing parts of this film is because Ryan O'Neill is, you know, Worts and all could share a screen with a nine year old on a toe to toe level. That was part of the joy of that watching that. Jack Nicholson could never do that. He never has done that. Watch him in any film. He is the actor. Everybody else's people there to serve him in the scene. I mean, that's that's my personal opinion.

18:24 Tell me how you really feel, Matt, Matt, I always know I'm going to get how you really That's what I love about you, man. Okay, one more Bob Evans regular. What about Warren Batty. I think Warren Baty would have been good in this film. I think Warren Beatty to me, Warren Beatty and Ryan O'Neil, it's like the same dude. It been interchangeable. Yeah. I think the one intangible that we have to look back to is the fact that Ryan and Tatum O'Neil were father and daughter. That comes through in this film, even though they're supposedly not related. I will cast you back to the idea that the name of the movie was originally called Addie Prey. It wasn't Addie Loggins. So there's an intangible there of having the two of them as father and daughter in the film that I believe does come through. Now let's move to Tatum O'Neill, Lucas.

19:15 Yeah, that's something I get. I'm not complain on the saying it'll take it through Lucas. I'm gotay, I get it. Those are pretty good talentent there. We could do some business in there. Well, what do you mean we're out of Bibles? Why didn't you tell me we're out of Bible? You give you you know you've got an excuse for everything by fish. If we're running out of Bible, she should have told me where we're running out of Bibles? Well, then we got to get a new one. Let's get new ones. We can pick them up in Great Bend. Great Ben's the other wrong. Feels like you already moved to Tatum. Yeah. I was trying to make it, but we've moved down To talk about the co star of this movie. I don't think she is the best supporting actress. I one hundred percent agree with you. She should have won Best Actress.

19:56 She wasn't a supporting actress. She was the whole movie. She was in there scene. You know, we looked at our running time for this film. I mean it's like an hour and forty minutes, but she's in it for like one hundred and six minutes. I mean she's in it for the majority. Now, I believe this is what I read. The reason why both she and Linda Blair were nominated for Supporting Actress was due to their age, and I think the awards have since changed so that you do have younger actors being nominated for leading roles. It is interesting to sort of give her her due. Tatam O'Neill wins the Academy Award and it was absolutely deserved, and like I said before, is actually deserved to be Best Actress because she is fully fifty percent of every scene she's in, if not more. There's many scenes where she is leading the scene.

20:44 You're absolutely right, Tatum O'Neill is the star of this show and that Ryan O'Neill's character is just reacting to her. That's all he has to do is react to Tatum. It comes off very genuine in the film, and I really I love. That this is why. I think it was W. C. Fields that said, don't ever appear with the child as an actor. You're always going to look bad compared to a precocious child. And I think this is essentially that. I believe that they always wanted this to be a father daughter combination because when they had floated Paul Newman, at the same time, they were also considering Nell Ponts his daughter to play Addie.

21:26 In thinking that Paul Newman might have had his daughter in to play Addie, I have to rethink my saying that Paul Newman might not have been right as Moe's. I think maybe with his daughter in it would have given that same dynamic that Ryan and Tatum had. So maybe a'll soften that statement that Paul Newman might have been able to play this if his daughter was playing the Addie character. What do you think of Miss Tricksie the Light played by Madeline Cohn? I just love it, love it, love it all. This why it is absolutely the thing for my particular kind of appearance. You know, it wouldn't be bad for you to have a new dress too. The right kind of dress makes all the difference in the days, especially since you got the right kind of bone structure. Oh oh, oh my, oh my, daddy, But wouldn't you look handsome sitting down on the wheel of a thing like that, because you know everything is in the bone structure. You know, a person can tell his whole life on what his bone structure is.

22:25 I try to push out. It was sort of the weirdest segue in a movie, You're on vacation. I mean, I've always liked Maddeline conn I think she said severely underrated actor. When I was looking at this, I found our next three actors would appear in Blazing Saddles. Yeah, Madeline Cohn who played Lil von Stoop That I said that, right, Lil von Stup, Little Deuce Cooper, and John Hillerman who played Howard Johnson, and then Burton Gilliam played Lyle. All three of them would appear next year in mel Brooks's Blazing Saddles. I think we could do a month of seventies movies, comedies that you could not make today, and I would put Blazing Saddles and The Jerk because those films are hilarious. Again, one of my favorites is Young Frankens.

23:07 Let's let's talk about John Hillerman. Now playing games with esmus Oh, I didn't know who was back there. It's a risky thing to do. I get your tires shut off. Were you in? Me and my little girl are going to Saint Joe. Oh live there nearby a bunch of business. Uh, livestock, mostly mules and horses, some cattle. That's funny. And heard us a bootlegger. Oh no, sir, not me. Friend, must be some mistake. Maybe maybe not the way I hear it. You just had a transaction by the old barn. Would you hear a thing like that? Oh, a friend of the family. I didn't really notice they were brothers. He takes dual Rose, Deputy Harden and his twin brother, Jess Harden. But it's funny now that you mentioned it, because now I look back and okay, that makes.

23:57 It slipped by me that they were the same actors, because the character of Jess Harden has a mustache, and you don't really see much of them. I see much more of Deputy Harden, who doesn't have the mustache. And I have to admit, in my mind, John Hillerman is always Higgins from Magnum Piah did not see him in this role. And then I was really blown away when I realized that he was Howard Johnson from Blazing Sapples. That is so funny. And he was a great character in Magnum p I, honestly very nuance. So it's funny that he had all these things he appeared in in the past, and then he ended up at Magnipi, which I think probably made more money than all the movies put together. Probably definitely. Those residuals are very kind. He's still making money from it.

24:43 The next actor that we wanted to mention was Burton Gilliam who plays Floyd and Floyd as a small role. He seems familiar, and of course that's when I see that he played Lyle in Blazing Saddles. Next we have actress PJ. Johnson who played I'm a Gene. She willly do all that dancing, but if you want to call it damns, all she'd do is wag a hips and shake over a little. How come she need that job at there? Because the boss made a job make up put out for his friends. Because she don't believe in putting off for free. She put out much just like a gum machine. It drops on in and she'll put somehow how much she charged most she can get, but she always asks five dollars. She ain't putting off your photo. She says, she's the one way to get all she can for.

25:33 She put out for him. She tell her he was my paw. Well not exactly. And p K was fifteen years old at the time and she is from Houston, Texas. She became something of a local movie celebrity in her hometown following the film's release, and PJ would reprise her role on the TV show and would also appear in the sequel to The Last Picture Show, which was called Texasville. She was very good in this film. Sad that we didn't see her in lots and lots of films. Last but not least in a very small, small role, maybe a cameo if you will, was Randy Quaid as Lee role. I'm laughing because he's so funny. It was quintessential. Randy Quaid played a big goofball who's going to wrestle with Moe's and it was hilarious. That's a great scene. Definitely look out for that when you watch the movie.

26:24 And movie audiences, we'll see a lot more of Randy Quaid when The last detail premieres in December of seventy three. All right, when we come back, we're diving into our thoughts on paper Moon, but first we need to take a quick break. Don't go anywhere. Nomadic flash Back, Dearly beloved, we are gathered here today to celebrate Death Dave's nineteen eighty four, a video podcast that will take you through the greatest pop culture year we have ever seen. My fellow American Slacks O s. I am a candidate, and we'll seek.

27:07 Reelection from movies, music, sports, comics, television, and more. This show will be a chronological journey through every aspect of the year. So who's going to drive you home and not let the glory days pass you by? Death Dave's nineteen eighty four. It's a hard habit to break, but time after. Time I'll show you why nineteen eighty four was the best year ever. So who you gonna call? Available? Now? Subscribe and follow today. I'll be back Amatic Flashback.

27:49 Lady, you may mistake, huh. I'll give you four dollars seventy five cents, but I give you a twenty dollars bill. Huh, huh, you give me a five No man, it was twenty dollars bill. You give me a. Five, and I'll give you four dollars and seventy five cents. It was a twenty dollar bill. Got no twenties in with no fives. What's all her? Turnoil? What's going on here? This little girl? Give me a five dollar bill and I give her change. I give her a twenty dollars bill. I know I did. It was a birthday present for my healing and Wichita, and she wrote happy Birthday Addy on the enemy. You just go look and see. That's it, right, dear, that's my twenty dollar bill I got for mine Helen and Wichita.

28:35 Give the child a twenty dollar bill. I'm giving it. Give the childer a twenty dollar bill. Miss Brownwell, yes, sir, Give her a piece of candy, Miss Brownwell, sir. Pay attention to things, mister. Brownwell, yes sir. Welcome back. Check and I are about to get into our thoughts about Paper Moon, so there may inadvertently be spoilers, so beware. This might be a good time to pause the podcast and watch the film. Paper Moon is not available on two, but you can rent it from wherever you rent movies. Okay, let's get into it. This movie, it feels really really simple, but it does shift the more you sit with it. When did that start happening with you? Almost right away, because the whole interaction during the opening scenes at the graveside really started to sort of tell that there's a lot more going on than sort of meeting the eye. That was just sort of what would you call a mouse boosh, nice, a little starter there. Nice. Once the interaction between Addie and Pray start to happen, you really start to see that there's there's going to be a lot more layers.

29:39 I found it interesting that in the very start of the film that you learn a little bit about Moe's as he even approaches the graveside. Now it's the graveside of ADDIE's mother. Mose walks up, he parks his car, he's walking up, he bends down, he picks up flowers off of another gravesite, walks over, and at some point after everyone's walking away, he looks down into the grave and says something along the fact of you know, you were a good woman, you know, kind of implying that there was maybe a one night stand kind of a relationship, and he throws the flowers down, but the film opens up on a tight close up of Addie. The expression that's on her face is an expression you're going to see throughout the whole film.

30:24 Just to add to your point about MOSE's appearance is not to forget that the car is, you know, backfiring and chugging and barely running as it comes up, So right off the bat, you know this guy is not a man of means or anything. And then he immediately steals the flowers like he described. At what point did you realize that maybe Mose wasn't exactly one hundred percent in charge? The moment Addie realizes that she could ask for that money and out of nowhere, she just says, I want. My two hundred dollars. Yeah, that's the moment that I think we thought Mose was in control because of how he was manipulating the owner of that mill, and then all of a sudden we realize that Addie has the power in this relationship.

31:10 What about you, Yeah, I think maybe you didn't point out one particular fact that anybody who's had a child knows that you cannot make them eat. You can ask them to eat, but the power lies with them. So in this scene, she absolutely is refusing to eat the food or drink the knee high. She is absolutely in control of that. And then so to me, when the and you owe me two hundred dollars pops out to me, it was like, yep, she's she's in control. It was great. It was a great scene. Whoever filmed it, the sort of harping on the coney dog because he must have said the word I don't know twelve times. It's repeated quite a minute. Yeah, And it's funny because she will not even touch it. She is one hundred percent in control at this point, and she knows it.

31:55 She brings out that you owe me two hundred dollars basically at the right moment when he's trying to make noise about how he's buying her a train ticket and he's buying her this food, and she just shuts him down. It's amazing. It's really good. One of the aspects that you see about Addie. She's lost her mother, but she is also looking for who her father is. She is looking at Moe's as a father figure. There's also a big hint that maybe Mo's is the father, whether. He knows it. Or not. Yeah, yeah, they definitely hint around about that. But I think it's unsettled on purpose, and I think it makes it a better film that it's unsettled. Sure, I was very surprised at how mature she was.

32:38 She immediately has that understanding about the two hundred dollars. A young kid her age and I may not have even been paying attention, but you notice that Addie is always paying attention. For example, when they start to do their Bible scam, Addie begins sizing up the women and the family at the door to be able to tell how much to pay for the Bible. Right right, there's this woman who obviously has twelve children. She can't afford a Bible. They actually give away the Bible, but then she goes up to the one woman's house, a very wealthy woman, and she charged them twenty four dollars. And it's sad because she only would have gotten that knowledge by living kind of a rough and tumble life with her mother, who was obviously a woman down on her luck. She frequented the bars and stuff. So you know, it's sad that Addie, as a young person, would already know these kinds of ins and outs and actually knows people better than Bray does. Right, he's very surface level.

33:37 She was definitely stepping past that into what these people needed to hear to get them to buy the Bible. So she's older than what her age would belie right, yeah, sure, more mature, Yeah, definitely much more mature. What did you think when she lit up that cigarette? Oh, that's so funny. It was so funny, but it was right along with what you're this iconoclastic little person sort of speaking adult words and sort of somewhat understanding and remembering. At the same time, this little girl just lost her mom, so she really has not had much of a chance to grieve. It's it's you know, it's bittersweet to me that it's like, she's okay, she's old enough and mature enough kind of deal with it. But at the same time, you're like, she's just a little kid, you know, she shouldn't have to deal with this. My takeaway, that wasn't her first cigarette she's ever. Oh no, she had it in the box.

34:29 I think she herself. She lit the match with her fingernail. But also, at the same time, she is tough, but she's also very vulnerable. Do you remember the scene where she's looking at herself in the mirror. She also carries this cigar box. In the bottom of the cigar. Box is all of her memories of her mother, like her pearls, her perfume. She wears her hat throughout the entire film. And you realize all of this because there's one single picture of her and her mother, And of course at leads to the I thought it was kind of a funny scene where she's splashing the perfume all over her, and then the payoff is the next day. But the greatest part is that is like you didn't even realize back in the old days, the windscreen came up, Yeah, you could open the front window. That was pretty funny.

35:19 That was a neat nostalgic thing. And the other thing we haven't even talked about, which is so funny to me. We didn't even talk about the whole films in black and white. Oh gosh, how could we forget that? I know, but it's one of those things where you know, it just doesn't seem to make a lot of difference, and it adds to the stark grayness of the times. You know, you're talking about the nineteen early nineteen thirties, right, and. It was actually nineteen thirty six, which was the same year that The Sting was to have taken place. Yeah, so it's still you're still coming out of the effects of the Great Depression, you know, so times are tough. The Black and White was a very interesting way to God, I feel like a seventies movie to you. Uh, I don't know, I think so. Yeah, gosh, I don't.

36:09 It doesn't hit. It doesn't have that same hit as a seventies movie. Yeah, I might agree with that. It's always hard to sort of figure out how they trying to emote the time of the film and what is the nuance that having a seventies film brings to the lens of the time they're filming. You know, it's very meta. I mean, you go down several years here. So after watching The Sting, I always felt like I was watching a movie, right, because it's so well produced, it's so well set everything. It feels like that that very well could have been a movie made in the seventies when I watch it. When I watched this film, this film could have been made much earlier because it's a low budgeted film and Bogdanovich is using. I think he's making the most of everything that he can within that budget limit that he has. Yeah agree with that that it all makes a lot of sense. So if you didn't know that the actor and actress playing Mose and Addie were father and daughter, would it play the same. I'll give you my take on it is. I think it endeared me to the movie. It gave me a predisposition of positivity to the movie before I watched it, because I thought it would be cool to see a father and daughter acting together. And I think you also saw that on Golden Pond with Henry Fonda and Jane Fonda, which is a fantastic movie, not a seventies movie, but still worth watching. That was a father daughter dynamic of two powerhouse actors in top form. In my opinion, Henry Fonda was an amazing actor, and in her own right,

37:41 Jane was as well. I think it gave me a positive predisposition to the film because I think it's cool that a father and daughter got to do this film, and she was so young and she won an Academy Award. I think it added something, but I don't think it would have been the end of the world if they weren't related. I definitely agree with you that the father and daughter relationship brought a lot of familiarity. You know how sometimes you watch child actors and it always feels like maybe they're not quite as up to snuff as the adult actors. It can sometimes it can be a little bit disjointed unless it plays into. How the role is written right. So I think, for example, here there's already conflict between the two. Mos really doesn't want her along until he realizes that she would be good for his con games as having a little girl with him. She's also looking for this father figure to fill a role in her life that she doesn't want to go off to live with her aunt and uncle. They keep repeating, you have the same jaw. It's so true. You look at them and you see it, you know through Wow. I think it adds a lot to the film, speaking of things that add a lot, and you can see things that maybe maybe was weird or didn't add so much. Sure, I think we have that whole segment of Tricksy Delight played by mattn To me, it felt like a big shift between Act one in Act three or something. I mean, it was like it was weird to me because Moe's made such a shift in his personality and his activities

39:12 and his going and buying. More cars, and it was weird. It was act too. I would bet that in the source material there's some more justification for this. In other words, it wouldn't like we all have read books and then we go to the movie and we're like, Okay, I'm filling in the banks here because oh that's the scene. I did enjoy it, but I know all the stuff that led up to it, that's why it happened. Whereas if you're somebody who's never read the book, you're like, why did that happen? You know? And that's where I was a little bit with this. But I did enjoy the scene because it kind of showed Addie at her full powers of discernment and the full on power of her ability to solve a situation.

39:52 You're going to ruin it, ain't you. Look, I don't want to wipe you out, and I don't want you wiping me out, you know, So I'm going to level with you. Okay, Now, I say with me, it's just a matter of time. I don't know why, but somehow I just don't manage to hold on me along. So if you wait it out, let it, it'll be over, you know. I mean, even if I want a fellow, somehow I managed to get it screwed up. Maybe I'll get a new past shoes, a nice dress, a few laughs. Times are hard. If you fool around on the hill up here, then you don't get nothing. I don't get nothing, You don't get nothing.

40:41 Madeline Con was amazing in this film. I loved the character. She is the foil if you will with Addie. She is the one coming in between her and Moe's. And you know that Addie does not like it, and I love that she finds a compatriot and I'm a chain. You know. I'm going to leave the details of their con but it's a fun saying. Well, hello, Cupid stricks. You want to see She says it's really important. Five Oh she does? Does she win right now? Well, I can't get. Off right now, but she says it's real important. Well, you tell her I'll come up later tonight when the moon is full.

41:25 But you can't come tonight. She won't even be here afternight. Matter of fact, she won't even be here after today. She won't huh, well, you won't be sorry. I guess I could go up for a few minutes. What's that room number again? Two thirty five? She's waiting for you. Okay, you tell her. I'm all the way up, so you are. You're gonna love it. It's the most complicated con in the entire film, and I wanted to say that if your heart just doesn't melt when Addie makes his little eyebrows raises up and down when she's intimating to Floyd the clerk as to what she's talking about.

42:08 It was very funny, and I would just it is great. I think it's a good idea to leave it to the audience to watch it because it's such a fun setup and orchestration of this thing, and then how it resolves is all very very very cool. We need to take a quick break, but we'll be right backmatic. Flash back. In the actual Egyptian Tomb of Green Look ready and featuring ulicious Miss Cheeter light. You did? I ain't that fun. Right now? Sweetheart? How are you taking minute? Not? Now?

42:48 You hear me? I can't help that, And excuse me, understand he can't gonna finish many times as I like that's how many times, and. I might see a half dozen more. Now, why don't you go play or something? I want to play bingo? Then why don't you go write another love note to Saint Roosevelt. Maybe I will. I stop standing around here checking on me. You don't have to worry. I ain't about to leave some poor little child stranded in the middle of nowhere. I got scruples too. You know you know what that is. Scruples. Yeah, I don't know where it is. But if you've gotten, be sure back. The roan somebody else. I wanted to bring up a thing about the film name because I think it sure it matters in this way, because the original name of the film was going to be Addie Prey, but after hearing the song It's Only a paper Moon, Brogdanovich renamed it, and he added a scene where Addie has her picture taken in a paper moon, specifically to justify using the title. But I think there's also another part of that photograph is that there was supposed to be a photograph of Mo's and Addie in the paper Moon, and it doesn't get taken, and she throughout the film carries around the photo of her and her mom. So I think there's a little tie in with that not happen. But it also you know, if you think about it, it not happening because they are together.

44:06 It happened with her mom, but her mom is not gone, So to me, it can be taken as a sort of positive or a negative. So you know, Matt, this is why I. Love having you as a co host here on the Cinematic Flashback podcast because I will do all of this research on stuff, and you will look at the film and you will just see what it is in all those deeper contacts that I just sometimes I don't pull out. I love your analysis, man, I just thought it was fun when I read that. I sort of then started to think on it a little bit, and then how that scene went with her being a little bit salty at not having a photo with him taken. I really do go backwards on some of these things because a film was very intentional, right that the director is telling us a story, and typically the stuff that doesn't tell the story gets left on the cutting room floor. So if he included that scene, he was trying to say something about it, right, which was, yeah, it's a picture of her mom. She would then have a picture of her dad. Yeah, but no it doesn't happen, So there's still it could be to his purpose of keeping that relationship nebulous. Is it real or is it? Is it real because they made it real?

45:16 Is only a paper more failing all a cardboardy. I went and looked at some of the words or paper moon. There's the line where it says, without your love, it's a honky tonk parade, without your love. It's a melody played and a penny arcade. It's a Barnum and Bailey. World's just as phony as it can be. But it wouldn't be. Make believe if you believed in me. That is the heart of what Addie is looking for, and that brings us to the ending. Is this actually a happy ending? I think it is because it basically says things are going to go on into the future with the two of them, and honestly, come what may. As it goes into the future, we don't know, but it's pretty clear that they're going to go into the future together, which I think is the best resolution. It also leaves it open for serialization in a series.

46:17 The final shot is of them driving down this long road. The road just goes on and on forever until the road goes over the horizons. So I felt it resolved a lot. I don't want to go any more details about which happens at the during the ending sequence because it is, it's moving, and it's nice in the film to see it. But I do think that last scene was interesting because one of the things I liked is they this truck that they got was such a ramshackle truck from Leroy. They absolutely had to work together to get it down the road, which I think was significant. Right, they had to push it to go, she was driving, he was running behind, and then climbs in Yeah, there you go again.

46:59 I love that. To me, that was sort of the Okay, we're we're now going to work together and not against each other, right, We're gonna yeah, we're in this together, which was to me sort of the best, the best ending you could look for, because obviously in a film like this, you're always waiting for the other shoe to drop. Is something going to happen to one of them or the other, I mean something really bad, and so it is one of those there's a bit of tension. So this scene at the end is very very nice, in my opinion, really joyful. It doesn't it doesn't resolve any questions other than the fact that they're going to work together. Man, I think it's time to ask a question. Did Paper Moon groove through the decades or did it lose its beat?

47:43 So I'll answer this way. I went into this thinking that I would not enjoy this movie. I mean, honest to goodness, I had ever seen it before. But I really there are a lot of stories about Ryan and Tatum O'Neill out there and their stormy relationships through their lives, which it's just nothing but sad. All of that was just not very pleasant. But all of that notwithstanding, I enjoyed this film. The dynamic of Addie and Mo's was the whole thing. The relationship is formed, it grows and comes to fruit all within the film, and to me, that is why the open ended ending feels right. They are going to go along together from that point on, not in a traditional relationship, but maybe in the healthiest one each one has ever had so far in their lives.

48:27 I declare this film still grews. However, not having seen it back in the day, I am not sure if it groofed back in the Day. I enjoyed it, and I highly recommend it. Matt the thirty million dollars it made at the box office says that it grooved back in the day figure. One of the things that I kept thinking about this movie. In some ways it just reminded me of watching A Little Rascals. Yeah, the children in the Little Rascals were always in control and they always drove the story. One of the things that I love about The Last Picture Show was how Bogdanovitch transported me to a small dying town in Texas. One striking quality of that film was that he chose to shoot it in black and white, and I was very surprised to see that he was able to do it again in Paper Moon. I'm excited to see What's Up Doc later in December. I knew from the moment that Addie demanded her two hundred dollars that I was going to like this film, and the rest of the movie just proved me right, even if sometimes I wasn't really sure where it was going. Unfortunately, when you research a movie, you come across the rather tragic tale of the O'Neills, and it is rather sad because you so want to believe what you see on the screen, because what you see on the screen is a sweet ending that I really wish that the two of them could have had in real life. But I agree with the consensus on Rotten Tomatoes and I think this movie still grooves. Comparing this to The Sting, I think the Sting has a much more satisfying closing, but

49:59 I think the Paper Moon has so much more heart. I would agree with your analysis one hundred percent. I do think that the Sting wraps everything together much like we said in that podcast, sort of like the old episodes of Mission Impossible, where every single thing works correctly, click bang, everything's in a small box and everything worked, and that's very satisfying at your sort of analytical level. This movie none of that happens. None of everything is kind of click click click, and everything works. It's all kind of a seat of the pants. But like you point out, I think this has more heart. Well. That wraps up our art of the con month.

50:45 Coming in June, we're kicking off our Origin series where we take a look at the early films of two directors who would leave a massive mark on seventy cinema. First, we head into the Far Future with George Lucas. This is THCHX eleven thirty eight, a dystopian vision of a world where the prison doors are completely unlocked, but humanity has been conditioned not to care. Then we hit the highway and have a deadly run in What the Truck as we drive deep into the desert with Steven Spielberg's Duel. Both of these films revealed talents that are just about to explode onto the cinematic landscape, with ideas and themes that these directors will continue to expand on for years to come. We're really looking forward to diving into these films with you.

51:36 Thanks for tuning in. Let us know what you thought about Paper Moon. You can reach us at Wwwcinematicflashback dot com and don't forget to leave us a rating and a review. We might just read it on air or make a call out to you for your contribution and your comments. If you enjoy the show, help us grow by sharing it with your friends. Really be that person who annoys your friends by saying you have you listened to this podcast? It's pretty good? Join us next time as we hop back into the wayback machine and head once again into the nineteen seventies for another classic. We'll see you then. Sure this little baby has to go wake you tanky all the time.

52:29 Well, don't you worry none. We'll just plan on stopping here for dinner. But we just stopped for it, and we that line. That's right, And now we're stopping for dinner. Come on, I ain't hungry.